Finally, Neda’s Staged “Killing” Exposed

by Scott Creighton

On June 24, 2009 I wrote an article called “Compare and Contrast: One is Real the Other is Fake” which explained how I thought the Neda killing in Iran was a staged attempt to ferment indignation in Iran and the rest of the world against the ruling party that had just won the election. It was yet another example of an attempt to overthrow a regime that was unfriendly to U.S. corporations and bankers probably devised by the CIA like so many in the past. I have done several stories on the Iranian Election Propaganda campaign that was designed to give cause to overthrow Iran.

Well, even some of my regulars here thought I had gone overboard on that one. But now there is a documentary out now showing clearer images of the entire thing and you can see it’s an obviously staged event. She’s got the tube of fake blood in her left hand and you can see her apply it to her own face after it squirts out a bit and runs down her hand and down her arm. She then drops the tube of fake blood and the doctor who helped stage the event tries to push it under her so the camera won’t see it. 

Then they had to restage the propaganda “money shot” sometime later and they screwed that up in a rushed effort to get it out and on the front page of every newspaper in the world while the story was breaking. Of course they had no real concern about it being an accurate recreation of the scenen since they already knew “journalists” like Andrew Sullivan were already in the bag.

Unfortunately for Neda, she was too young to realize that when people like this stage fraudulent “events” in order to try to install their neoliberal regime in a country, it doesn’t do to have the martyr of the revolution running around, so they probably killed her later… apparently by shooting her in the back. This gives you a little insight into the kinds of people who would help to install a neoliberal regime on the population of a nation (like our congress). They care about one thing and one thing only… money (like our congress).

Phony liberal pundits like Andrew Sullivan breathlessly blogged for weeks and weeks non-stop about how “poor little Neda” was killed by the big bad Mullah regime in Iran. But he has dutifully ”reported” on every single PR campaign story coming out of Iran and it’s CIA backed “Green Revolution”.  I wonder what he will say when he finds out that it was all a hoax and that Nada was actually killed, shot in the back, by neoliberal “friends of the West” in Iran. I wonder how “breathless” he will get about that? I guess the death of Nada is only meaningful to neoliberal sympathisers like Sullivan when it serves their overall agenda.

When Neda’s real death serves to expose the criminality and the brutality of those who work to usher in neoliberal “reform”, it isn’t so much of a story anymore.  At least that would be my guess as far as Andrew Sullivan is concerned. If that is true, after all his breathless propaganda about her obviously staged fake death scene, well then he might as well have shot the girl in the back himself. You see, without knowing that they had mouthpieces like Andrew Sullivan all ready to report their Neda story to the rest of the world and the blogs without really looking at it too closely, the people who planned this would never have done it.  So you can say, for all his weeping and gnashing of his teeth about “poor little Neda”, Andrew Sullivan did his part and therefore might as well have pulled the trigger himself.

I just became aware of the video evidence during Iran’s June 2009 election of Neda Agha-Soltan that shows her pouring a red substance over her own face that is caught by the video. I had to watch about six times to verify that I really did see Neda apply the “blood” to her face. This staged event ended with Neda’s real death; her autopsy reported her cause of death was a close-range shot to the back rather than the US corporate media report of sniper-fire to the chest. I couldn’t find confirmation in English of her autopsy and welcome reader links. I thank one of my favorite websites for the alert: What Really Happened.

11 Responses

  1. That is so horrible… when you posted your article about her and the fake death… yeah, i could see what you were talking about…. and I visualized that girl still alive and living in some new area… probably rich from her part in the death scene…
    and they killed her… ..of course…. they couldn’t have her alive…. and she probably never saw it coming…
    that is horrible… killing your props….
    we are worse than wild animals… well, not all of us… we are just capable of such hateful extremes…..

  2. A belated well-done to you willy. Somehow I missed the original posting. If the US/Israel get their way, there’ll be thousands more Nedas in the great “saving the world from Iran” show coming soon to a theatre (of war) near you.

  3. Are you really a moron or u have chosen to be one?
    watch this video from another angle and watch her empty hands and the blood gushing out of her nose and mouth:

  4. thank you so much for providing that… now I will be able to compare this one side by side to the other one.

    curious how her left arm goes all fuzzy when it moves.

  5. Finally, the world looks like it might be coming around:

    BUT I am sorry, this new video, posted over a year after the original video, does not comport with the same video posting.
    It is much clearer, and much more graphic, AND here we see the blood just blooming out of her nose, with no hands even near were they were in the previous video.

    We also see obviously removed shadows, body motions that weren’t in the original video, blood streams that seem to have a life of their own, and numerous artifacts peppered all over the video.
    I hate to say it, but I think this rendition has been seriously video edited with CGI effects post applied.
    Look very carefully at the blood, and the position and resolution of the hands’ location.

    I am not sure if the original hoaxters did this, or some independent compatriot did, but it has obviously been doctored (nopunintended?)

    The only wild card here that I didn’t expect, was the Neda might have been actually killed post staging.

    I would wonder though, if they were going to kill her anyway, why didn’t they just make a simple snuff film, and accuse the police and Basiji for it. Why would they stage it, then kill her?

    If indeed Neda did eventually wind up dead, and I am still skeptical about that, I would guess it was much later, after she refused to go underground into hiding indefinitely, and didn’t want to continue the hoax, and then the creators of the hoax saw no other option.

    (BTW, I am the author of another skeptical analysis of the Neda shooting, published on the same day June 24, 2009 that Scott Creighton posted his skeptical analysis.
    Great minds do think alike, and in sync :-)

  6. Forgot to mention -

    That other article is:

    Was the Neda Agha-Soltan video a Hoax?

    http://www.nolanchart.com/article6565.html

  7. Thank you for posting this info and the link to the other article.

    I saw the other video and I too couldn’t help but feel it was CGI… the blood kind of gives it away. Looks like they repositioned her hand and did other things to it.

    thanks again for the link.

    I am scott creighton by the way.

  8. I’m sorry. But you guys are submitting to the international question of whether or not Americans are dumb ignorant people.

    I’m an Iranian, and am expecting to be criticized an rejected, but possibly I can introduce an idea to you.

    This revolution is a very serious matter. By nit-picking a video of somebody’s questionable death, I feel you are disrespecting the thousands of people who have died from government police basiji attacks, which i have SEEN WITH MY OWN EYES. It disturbs me you put shame on Neda like this. You have such little idea of what our people are living through, massive killings carried out by the government, and all you can do is criticize our protests and go the length to us using propaganda.

    We have suffered so much. You have never treated us like people.

  9. what happened? did you guys get all excited to start up another business friendly CIA “revolution” after watching the success of your thug brothers in Egypt, the ones beating the real protesters?

  10. Cyrus:

    My meta-opinion of the matter is different than the author of this article, although we are both skeptical that the Neda video depicts a true event, see my article at http://www.nolanchart.com/article6565.html

    As I stated in that article, I am all for the Iranian protesters and their demonstrations for democracy, and I have doubts that Neda was actually killed at all even to date.
    My issue is with the video and the manipulation of public opinion, even for the best of causes, by the issuance of this fraudulent video.

    I hope and wish that the pro-democracy movement in Iran succeeds; I know that the majority of Iranian people are good and optimistic and just want to live their lives unmolested by overlords.
    That is noble, and something I too fight for in America.

  11. since that fake revolution, like the other many “color” revolutions started up and staged by the CIA, the facts have come out and it is WELL KNOWN that the entire thing was a fraud.

    The elections were honest, as reported even then by MANY international observers.

    I know what you guys are doing. Someone in your group (Buson-Marsteller?) thinks now is a good opportunity to start up another fake revolution and maybe all of these REAL revolutions will give you cover.

    crisis = opportunity?

    its pretty sad of you actually.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 92 other followers